Friday, 12 November 2004

in the wake of the plague

Pop history indeed. I didn't quite throw it across the room, as I did with William Manchester's A World Lit Only by Fire--a stupid title for a book about the medieval Europe, since the entire world, not just Europe, was lit only by fire, up until Edison--except, you know, also by sunlight. I only skimmed the last few chapters. Unfortunately I bought two books by Norman Kantor. The other is a survey of antiquity, a period I'm not quite as attached to, so its unsupported conclusions, red herrings, and convenient glosses (meaing both elisions and definitions) might not piss me off as badly.

house of the scorpion

I had never read any Nancy Farmer before and picked her up only because she's won Newbery honors. I started with this because the other I borrowed, A Girl Named Disaster, looked more appealing (it starts out better than House starts, continues, or ends). House wasn't awful, but in the way of The Giver, I am too old. It might be a fine jumping-off point for kids to debate certain ideas, but it lacks cohesiveness for the adult reader.

I went along with opium and coca being grown in unsuitable climates; but it lost me when drug lords ruling a thin strip of country between post-Mexico and the U.S., farming narcotics and blocking illegal emigration, were granted their sovereignty in return for promising not to sell their crops to either country but only abroad.